| First Quarter 2013 | story by ANNE BROCKHOFF | photos by STEVEN HERTZOG |
When it comes to banks, Lawrence is spoiled for choice. Some 20 banks operate here, offering every service a customer might want. All of them are clearly part of the community, especially when it comes to supporting local nonprofits, organizations and events. But are they true “community” banks of the sort It’s a Wonderful Life’s George Bailey might have recognized? Answering that question is harder than you might think.
Size is the easiest way to define a community bank, and many industry analysts say any bank with less than $1 billion in total assets qualifies. Size doesn’t tell the whole story, though.
How a bank does business is just as important, and not only when it comes to classic films. According to a community banking study released by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation in December 2012, true community banks are locally controlled, emphasize traditional banking activities in a limited market area and prioritize long-term customer relationships.
In other words, they keep decisions and dollars at home – something the FDIC study says is undeniably good for local economies.
“Community banks foster economic growth and help to ensure that the financial resources of the local community are put to work on its behalf,” the study says.
Among Lawrence’s banks, four are based here: Douglas County Bank, Lawrence Bank, Peoples Bank and The University National Bank.
Their corporate address is part of what helps keep these banks’ focus on the community, says Ted Haggart, president and chief executive of Douglas County Bank, which has total assets of $285 million.
“This is where our interests lie,” Haggart says. “Our employees and their families live here, their kids go to the schools and they take part in so much community service.”
In the case of Douglas County Bank, that adds up to 82 employees, a dozen board members and its owner—the Beach family of Lawrence. The bank does about 90 percent of its business within the county, with six Lawrence locations and one in Eudora.
Lawrence Bank is also headquartered in Lawrence, and its six directors and its holding company’s shareholders all have ties to the city, bank president Les Dreiling says. It operates two locations with 18 employees and has total assets of $69.7 million.
Peoples Bank has nine Kansas branches and seven in New Mexico, but the ownership and corporate office is in Lawrence. The Winter family controls 95 percent of the bank, which has total assets of $441 million, according to fourth-generation Lawrence resident, board chairman and chief executive Wint Winter Jr.
The University National Bank, which has one location and total assets of $69.5 million, is also locally owned, according to its web site (UNB president Todd Sutherland did not respond to requests for an interview).
Together, these banks contribute directly to the Lawrence economy by keeping jobs, executive opportunities, shareholder profits and bank earnings in the community.
“We’re our own little engine in that way,” says Tim Metz, vice president of loan services for Douglas County Bank.
Perhaps even more important, though, is how local control impacts decision-making. Take the loan process at Douglas County Bank. When an applicant approaches the bank, she first meets with a local advisor to discuss the loan’s details.
The typical loan is then considered by an in-house loan department; larger loans are reviewed on-site by a loan committee. The largest loan requests are evaluated by another loan committee comprised of board directors.
Because all the decision-makers in Lawrence, the bank often has more flexibility when considering what Haggart calls unique loan opportunities.
“Sometimes when something doesn’t fit the mold or general guidelines, we’re able to say yes,” Haggart says. “There may be a special reason to make the loan, and knowing the character and financial background of our customers helps us do that.”
If an applicant doesn’t qualify, the bank works with them to get to that “yes.” Loan officers help them refine their business plans, seek alternative financing like Small Business Administration loans or match them with advisors like those at Lawrence’s Small Business Development Center.
“Most often, loans are not so much denied but we ask ‘have you thought about doing it this way?” Haggart says. “We counsel (applicants) and help them find alternatives or levels of loans that work for them.”
When that happens, small business customers often return when they need a home loan or other services.
“There’s a kind of loyalty that develops there,” Haggart says. “That’s really important in community banking.”
All bankers work hard to understand their local economies and customers. The difference between community banks and their larger competitors is that they tend to give that specialized knowledge greater weight when making lending decisions, the study says.
Known as relationship banking, it’s a hallmark of community banks, Dreiling says.
“We probably know the local economy better because we’re involved in the local economy,” he says. “It helps being a local bank, having local board members and having local people who understand the community you’re involved with.”
That approach clearly benefits entrepreneurs. In 2011, community banks held only 14 percent of total U.S. banking assets, yet they generated 46 percent of all small loans to farms and businesses, the FDIC study says.
Building relationships yields another benefit for community banks: fewer bad loans.
Community banks consistently reported lower average loss rates in residential real estate loans and loans to individuals from 1991 through 2011, according to the FDIC study. That was partly due to their emphasis on relationship banking, especially during economic downturns.
That’s not to say the current recession skipped Lawrence banks. Peoples Bank, which last year closed mortgages in all 50 states, suffered what Winter calls a “massive credit loss” in 2009.
“When the bottom dropped out of the real estate market, we took a good, big hit,” he says. The bank is now experiencing a turnaround, and in 2012 further reduced its bad asset levels, increased its capital and generated net income of nearly $5.5 million.
Even banks that didn’t suffer credit losses found conditions challenging. While community banks saw a jump in deposits as customers sought so-called “safe havens,” historically low interest rates prevented that growth from translating into profit.
That’s because low rates reduce net interest income, or the difference between the interest rate a bank charges on loans and how much it pays on deposits. Community banks especially felt the squeeze, because net interest income typically accounts for about 80 percent of their revenue, compared to two-thirds of revenue at non-community banks, the FDIC study says.
And while a bump in deposits meant community banks had more funds available to lend, the slow economy slashed loan demand. There were simply fewer people buying or building homes, and fewer businesses opening or expanding.
“If you don’t have new business and industry opening up, you don’t have the opportunities to make loans,” Dreiling says.
The University of Kansas proved a stabilizing force on both jobs and real estate, but growth in Lawrence has stagnated in recent years. That may be changing, however.
Haggart, Winter and other local bankers are cautiously optimistic about an uptick in home sales and both residential and commercial construction. More entrepreneurs are seeking loans for new businesses, Dreiling says.
“We’ve handled probably half a dozen small business loans in the last six months on start-ups, primarily in Downtown,” he says.
Even after Lawrence’s economy rebounds, community banks will still face other pressures, especially on the regulatory front.
“The amount of regulatory burden coming out of D.C. and toward our community banks is absolutely staggering,” says Shawn Mitchell, president and chief executive of the Community Bankers Association of Kansas.
The passage in 2010 of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act, along with the controversial formation of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, means new regulations for banks. Basel III, which is meant to globally standardize bank capital and other requirements, is also expected to impact current rules.
Proponents say the changes are necessary to protect consumers. Critics counter that reforms address businesses and practices that aren’t relevant for community banks, ignore their unique structure and saddle them with an undue regulatory burden.
Either way, change is inevitable, and figuring out how to manage the new regulations and putting the information technology systems in place to do it will cost banks time and money.
“IT and compliance are some of the fastest-growing costs we have,” Dreiling says.
Like many community banks, The Lawrence Bank is too small to warrant its own IT department. Instead, a designated employee handles some issues in-house and the bank contracts with Sanders Software Consulting in Lawrence to oversee others.
It also shares compliance personnel with Great American Bank of De Soto; the two banks are both owned by holding company First Financial Bancshares.
So, what about the rest of the town’s banks? There are others that count as community banks, even though Lawrence isn’t their home community.
“It goes to the mentality of the bank, not the location,” the CBAK’s Mitchell says. “Even if they’re branched in other towns, they can be just as loyal to those towns as they are to their own.”
Central National Bank of Junction City is that kind of bank, says Jay Smith, the bank’s Lawrence market president. The family-owned bank dates back to 1884; it now operates in 22 communities and has total assets of $858 million.
“We’re an in-state owned bank that really understands Kansas,” Smith says. “We’re in places like Tipton, White City, Glen Elder and Hillsboro. Those aren’t the profit centers larger banks go after.”
Community banks are often the only banks in small, rural towns, the FDIC says, and they hold a majority of banking deposits in rural counties and micropolitan areas with an urban core population of between 10,000 and 50,000.
Lawrence has plenty of other out-of-towners, too, including the $228 million First State Bank & Trust of Tonganoxie and Capital City Bank of Topeka, which has total assets of $410 million. There’s the publicly traded Landmark Bank, small specialists with mortgage production offices in Lawrence, regional bank outposts and branches of some of the country’s largest financial institutions.
They all bring something unique to the table, and Lawrence’s locally owned community banks welcome the competition.
“A good, healthy banking environment with competition helps everybody,” Lawrence Banks’ Dreiling says. “It keeps banks competitive and allows the customers to have the opportunity to get the best deal.”
48 Comments
Licensed online pharmacy AU: Online drugstore Australia – online pharmacy australia
online pharmacy australia: Pharm Au 24 – Pharm Au24
get antibiotics quickly get antibiotics without seeing a doctor over the counter antibiotics
This is my first time pay a visit at here and i am in fact happy to read everthing at one place.
Over the counter antibiotics for infection: buy antibiotics online uk – get antibiotics without seeing a doctor
Ero Pharm Fast order ed pills online Ero Pharm Fast
Pharm Au 24 pharmacy online australia pharmacy online australia
Viagra sans ordonnance livraison 24h: Viagra sans ordonnance 24h – acheter Viagra sans ordonnance
livraison rapide Viagra en France: commander Viagra discretement – commander Viagra discretement
cialis prix: traitement ED discret en ligne – Cialis générique sans ordonnance
Pharmacies en ligne certifiees acheter medicaments sans ordonnance Pharmacie en ligne livraison Europe
acheter kamagra site fiable: kamagra gel – livraison discrete Kamagra
Viagra generique en pharmacie: viagra en ligne – Viagra sans ordonnance 24h
livraison discrète Kamagra: acheter Kamagra sans ordonnance – achat kamagra
cialis sans ordonnance traitement ED discret en ligne Cialis pas cher livraison rapide
Acheter Cialis 20 mg pas cher: Cialis pas cher livraison rapide – Acheter Cialis 20 mg pas cher
kamagra pas cher: kamagra livraison 24h – kamagra pas cher
Pharmacies en ligne certifiees: pharmacie internet fiable France – pharmacie en ligne fiable
Medicaments en ligne livres en 24h pharmacie en ligne sans prescription pharmacie en ligne pas cher
kamagra livraison 24h: achat kamagra – kamagra pas cher
traitement ED discret en ligne: cialis prix – cialis prix
kamagra en ligne kamagra oral jelly kamagra pas cher
pharmacie en ligne: pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance – Pharmacie sans ordonnance
viagra en ligne: Viagra générique en pharmacie – commander Viagra discretement
Medicaments en ligne livres en 24h: pharmacie en ligne – Pharmacie Internationale en ligne
livraison rapide Viagra en France prix bas Viagra generique Viagra gГ©nГ©rique pas cher livraison rapide
Cialis pas cher livraison rapide: Cialis sans ordonnance 24h – Cialis générique sans ordonnance
livraison discrete Kamagra: commander Kamagra en ligne – acheter Kamagra sans ordonnance
Cialis sans ordonnance 24h: Cialis generique sans ordonnance – acheter Cialis sans ordonnance
pharmacie en ligne fiable: pharmacie en ligne pas cher – pharmacie en ligne
acheter kamagra site fiable kamagra livraison 24h commander Kamagra en ligne
pharmacie internet fiable France: acheter medicaments sans ordonnance – trouver un mГ©dicament en pharmacie
pharmacie en ligne: Medicaments en ligne livres en 24h – п»їpharmacie en ligne france
viagra sans ordonnance: Viagra générique en pharmacie – acheter Viagra sans ordonnance
viagra en ligne Meilleur Viagra sans ordonnance 24h Viagra sans ordonnance 24h
acheter Viagra sans ordonnance: commander Viagra discretement – viagra en ligne
achat kamagra: kamagra oral jelly – kamagra 100mg prix
pharmacie en ligne france fiable: pharmacie internet fiable France – pharmacie en ligne france livraison belgique
pharmacie en ligne sans prescription pharmacie en ligne france pas cher pharmacie en ligne france pas cher
Acheter Cialis: commander Cialis en ligne sans prescription – traitement ED discret en ligne
pharmacie en ligne pas cher: acheter médicaments sans ordonnance – vente de médicament en ligne
livraison rapide Viagra en France: Acheter du Viagra sans ordonnance – Acheter Sildenafil 100mg sans ordonnance
kamagra en ligne vente de mГ©dicament en ligne kamagra pas cher
SildГ©nafil Teva 100 mg acheter: Viagra generique en pharmacie – Acheter du Viagra sans ordonnance
pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance: pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance – Achat médicament en ligne fiable
prix bas Viagra generique viagra sans ordonnance Viagra sans ordonnance pharmacie France
cialis generique: Cialis sans ordonnance 24h – Acheter Cialis 20 mg pas cher
viagra en ligne: viagra sans ordonnance – Meilleur Viagra sans ordonnance 24h